The Journal · The Brantford Club
Formal Attire and Black Tie, Read Off the Card by a Club That Prints One
Formal attire on a North American invitation usually means black tie or its nearest equivalent: a tuxedo or dinner jacket with a bow tie for men, a floor-length gown or a formal cocktail dress for women. Black tie optional admits a dark suit and tie. White tie is the top rung: tailcoat, white waistcoat, white bow tie, a full-length gown.
Three words carry more weight on a card than any other line on it. The Brantford Club reads them from both sides: it prints a dress code for its own dining room at 98 George Street in Brantford, and it has watched hosts raise that code to black tie for a dinner in a private room since 1898. Here is the ladder.
Dinner, a few rungs down
On an ordinary evening the dining room at 98 George Street sits a few rungs down this ladder, at smart casual, and you need not be a member to come to it for a first dinner. Tell the house which date suits you and how many chairs to set, and leave the dinner jacket on its hanger.
What does formal attire mean?
Formal attire is the dress code at the top of the evening range, and on most invitations printed in Canada it is a polite way of writing black tie. A man wears a dinner jacket, which Merriam-Webster defines under its American name, tuxedo, as “a semiformal evening suit for men,” the word semiformal being the dictionary’s reminder that a rung exists above it. A woman wears a gown to the floor or a formal dress in an evening cloth. Hosts print formal when they want black tie without the words. Read it as black tie, or, without the jacket, as black tie optional.
| On the card | He wears | She wears |
|---|---|---|
| White tie | Tailcoat, white waistcoat, white bow tie, patent shoes | A full-length gown |
| Black tie | Dinner jacket, braided trousers, black bow tie, black shoes | A floor-length gown or a formal dress in evening cloth |
| Black tie optional | A dinner jacket, or a dark suit and dark tie | A gown, or a formal cocktail dress |
| Formal | Read as black tie; a dark suit when the host says so | A gown or a formal dress to the knee or calf |
| Semi-formal | A dark suit and tie | A cocktail-length dress or dressy separates |
| Cocktail | A dark suit; tie by the invitation | A dress at or near the knee, or a jumpsuit |
Each rung admits the one above it at a stretch, never the one below. An engagement dinner usually stops short of formal, at cocktail attire or smart casual.
For Men: the Dinner Jacket and Everything Beneath It
The dinner jacket is black or midnight blue, its lapels faced in silk. The trousers match, carry a silk braid down the seam, and take no belt; braces hold them. The shirt is white, with studs where buttons would be. A cummerbund or a low-cut black waistcoat covers the waistband. Shoes are black patent or a polished black oxford. The bow tie is black silk and it is tied by hand; a pre-tied clip is visible from across a room because it is symmetrical in a way no tied bow ever is, and a slightly crooked bow reads as tied.
The old rule kept the watch off at black tie, since a guest at a dinner has nowhere to be; it survives at white tie. Elsewhere a thin dress watch on a black strap passes; a steel sports watch does not. The Club’s Committee made a cousin of the old rule on May 28, 1911: no member was to be interrupted by the telephone.
A black suit is the question every man without a dinner jacket asks. At black tie optional it stands in fully: black suit, white shirt, black tie, black shoes. At black tie it does not; the matte cloth, the belt loops, and the plain lapels read as a suit under any light. Rent a dinner jacket, or ask the host.
For Women: the Hem, the Cloth, the Wrap, and the Shoes
A gown to the floor is always correct at black tie and is the only correct answer at white tie. A formal dress that stops at the knee or at mid-calf passes at black tie and black tie optional, provided the cloth belongs to the evening: silk, satin, crepe, velvet, taffeta, lace, chiffon. Cotton, linen, and jersey knit belong to daylight. Colour is open, with two exceptions: white, ivory, and champagne stay with the bride at a wedding, and a memorial dinner keeps to dark tones. Shoes are a heel or a dress flat in satin, patent, or velvet.
A gala in a Canadian January is walked into through snow. A long wool coat or a velvet stole goes over the gown from the car to the door and is checked at the cloakroom. Boots to the door and shoes in a bag are the practice.
Where the Card Gets Printed
Black tie and formal attire turn up on five kinds of invitation. A gala reads formal as black tie without exception, and an awards dinner reads it the same way because the winners are photographed on a stage. New Year’s Eve reads it at black tie; the first evening at The Brantford Club was a New Year’s Eve, December 31, 1898, by the City of Brantford’s heritage record. A wedding after six reads formal as black tie. A regimental or club dinner reads it against the house’s own printed code.
The Brantford Club’s posted rules for the house set down its everyday floor: “Dining Room dress code is ‘Smart Casual.’ Collarless t-shirts, shorts, ripped jeans and hats are not permitted.” That floor holds on an ordinary Thursday. A black-tie evening in a private room is the host’s card raising it: the jacket the dining room welcomes becomes a dinner jacket, and the collar it requires takes a bow tie. The house never prints the higher code; the host does.
A bow tie has been tied in the front hall at 98 George Street on the last night of the year since 1898, and the house has never once printed the words that asked for it.
“Our dining room code is the floor, not the ceiling. When a host prints black tie on the card, the card wins, and the room rises to it. That is the host’s evening, not ours.”
Sabrina Van Leeuwen, Club Manager
Caught at the Coat Check
- The clip-on bow
- Symmetrical, and therefore visible. Learn the knot.
- A long black tie at black tie
- Correct at black tie optional with a suit; at black tie it belongs on the waiter.
- Brown shoes, or a belt
- Both are daytime. Black shoes, braces, no belt.
- A cocktail dress in a cotton print
- The hem is fine; the cloth is the giveaway. Evening cloth, or a gown.
- Guessing at white tie
- A dinner jacket at white tie is underdressed. Rent the tailcoat.
1888, Tuxedo Park, and a Hotel Door in 1923
The Victoria and Albert Museum keeps a black evening suit made by Morris & Co. around 1885, cut with tails, and its record gives the dinner jacket a birth year: “In 1888 the dinner jacket was introduced for more informal evening wear. Unlike the evening dress suit, which was cut with tails, the back of the dinner jacket was cut whole.” The American name arrived a year later: Merriam-Webster traces tuxedo to “Tuxedo Park, New York” and dates its first known use to 1889. The dictionary prints the place and no story, and so does this page. The Club first opened its door on December 31, 1898, when the dinner jacket was ten years old.
A second V&A record, for a dinner suit of 1928 to 1929, says dinner suits were “fashionable for informal occasions such as evening parties, the theatre and concerts,” while tails “were correct for dances, assemblies and public dinners,” and adds: “In 1923 a West End hotel reportedly turned away a man for wearing a dinner jacket to a dance.” Merriam-Webster dates white-tie to 1876 and black-tie to 1933. The card that reads formal today asks for the jacket the hotel refused.
Asked with the card on the fridge
What does formal attire mean on an invitation?
It means black tie or the nearest thing a guest owns to it: a dinner jacket and bow tie for men, a floor-length gown or a formal dress in evening cloth for women. Hosts print formal when they want black tie without the words.
Is formal the same as black tie?
On an evening invitation, yes. Black tie names the garments outright; formal describes the result and leaves the guest to work back to them. A host who writes formal is likelier to forgive a dark suit.
What is black tie optional?
A code that admits two correct answers in one room: a dinner jacket with a black bow tie, or a dark suit with a dark tie. Women wear a gown or a formal cocktail dress either way. The host is asking for black tie and excusing anyone who does not own it.
Can a man wear a black suit instead of a tuxedo?
At black tie optional, yes, with a white shirt, a black tie, and black shoes. At black tie the suit reads as a suit under any light, because of the matte cloth and the plain lapels. Rent a dinner jacket, or ask the host.
What is white tie?
The top rung, and a rare one. Men wear a black tailcoat, a white waistcoat, a white bow tie, and patent shoes; women wear a full-length gown. Merriam-Webster dates the phrase to 1876. In Canada it appears at state dinners and a few balls.
Sources: the V&A’s records for an evening suit by Morris & Co., ca. 1885 and a dinner suit of 1928 to 1929; Merriam-Webster on tuxedo, black-tie, and white-tie; the Club’s policies page (all read September 2026). Beneath this one sit the semi-formal rung, what a cocktail invitation asks, and, by day, business formal attire.
The Brantford Club, 98 George Street, Brantford, Ontario N3T 2Y4 · Open in Google Maps
A card that says black tie, and a room that answers it
A black-tie dinner wants a room that closes. The Brantford Club has two on that scale: the Main Floor Dining Room, up to sixty at table, and the Large Boardroom upstairs, also up to sixty, with a bar on request. The house asks the host for a date and a head count, and never for a membership card. The bar runs as cash, host, or a mix, and a deposit equal to the room fee holds the date; the rest is on the booking page. Send the occasion and the count, and Sabrina Van Leeuwen, the Club Manager, writes back with the room and the hour the doors open.
Email about a black-tie dinner
manager@thebrantfordclub.com · 519-752-0931 · Book the Club

